We have Papa John's, Dominos, Pizza Hut, OIP (Original Italian Pizza) around here but we tried them all except for the newest Vito's Coal-Fired Pizza all in a 5 mile area and we're a small town/rural area.
We used to love Pizza Hut but they went downhill in the past few years. It just didn't have any taste. A mile from us is 4 places called Pottsville Pizzeria (in business for 45 years and is all Sicilian style pizza- and that's all they do except for subs), Valenti's (they're okay), Suglia's (fantastic everything), and Dino's (they're okay in a pinch). We get a lot of stuff from Suglia's, not only pizza, but stromboli, wings, steak sandwiches, salads inlcuding Taco Salad, chicken and shrimp dinners ) etc. Hubby loves their wings and stromboli and their Suglia Special pizza which is loaded with everything but the kitchen sink and he gets a craving for their food at least once every 2 weeks.
Sadly they're moving to the Valenti building in the middle of town (no parking) and Valenti's is moving 7 miles away.