Favorite American Idol judge

[mrbizzard]

Who is your favorite American Idol Judge?
It could be a judge from the older seasons, to the judges now.

[msmoneybags48]

If I had to go through all the judges for American Idol until now, I would choose Randy Jackson.  I hate he had to leave.  I still assert that Nicki Minaj was the worst judge they ever brought in.  Inasmuch as I didn't like Simon Cowell, I liked her even less.

[lynnc35]

I don't watch American Idol, its stupid. Just like the rest of the dancing and junk shows they got on a waste of time, get up, get out and do something instead of watching other people do it.

[cathy37]

I guess I would have to pick Randy Jackson.  He has been with American Idol from the beginning and he seems to be fair with his comments and doesn't try to be ugly about his comments.  I really hate to see him go next year.

[cyncity831]

Simon will always be the best for me.  But I must admit I though Jennifer Lopez did a fantastic job at judging.  Definitely better than what Minaj and Carey did.  That's for sure.

[sherryinutah]

I have great appreciation for Keith Urban.  I think he's a keeper as long as he wants the job.  

[ricdsm]

Simon was my favorite.  After he left I lost interest in Idol.

[nannycoe1]

I still like Simon the best, but I hardly ever watch it anymore. The Voice is the best talent show by far I love it. Does anybody else think so?

[melissaotto1982]

Steven Tyler!! He cracked me up on the show!

[dancer139]

wow,,,,  thats a hard one,,   But I think it would be  Steven Tyler.  I think the show has run its course but I guess we will see what happens next year. 

[LaTashaS28]

I don't look at it like I use too but when I did...my favorite judge of all time was Paula, Randy Jackson, and Mariah Carey was an ok judge for a minute when she was up there this past season.

[tjung10]

I watched about a half hour of it this year! By far the best judge in my book was Simon!
If I had to pick another it would be Randy dawg Jackson!

[LenoraMinogue]

I don't really watch American Idol, but I imagine Steven Tyler was fun to watch.

[ljrjess69]

I don't watch the show so I cant say!

[bazodee]

I did like Simon and i will miss Randy but i did like Keith Urban as a judge! Glad Niki Minaj is going, couldnt stand her facial expressions and when she would fake a british accent! Waz up with the fake blond wigs with the dark roots!