Which do you prefer, Macaroni or Potato Salad?

[nguzman1]

I love potatoes so I would say potato salad

[catchow]

Im not sure I could choose a favorite! I make both the same way, except one has macaroni, the other potatoes But the same dressing, I add eggs and onions to both

[mjoseph1]

unfair to make me choose, they go great together, so i must have both lol

[cateyes1]

I actually like them both

[mrrangerrick]

Potato salad is the best...as long as it's homemade!!!!

[bowrunner]

I much prefer potato salad as I don't think macaroni salad has much of a taste.  I've been planning on making potato salad and I've cooked the potatoes twice now but after while they go bad in the refrigerator so I've not been able to make it yet.  I finally bought some yesterday but it's not nearly as good as homemade.

[masked_brown_guy]

I like potato salad more because I feel like I am eating hearty. Macaroni gives me a false sense of hunger satisfaction.

[mholt7]

I like both potatoe salad and macaroni salad.  But only if they dont have those crunchy thimgs like celery and relish, or onions.  We have it for holidays and cookouts.
 

[shepherdchik]

That all depends, homemade I love both. Store bought I usually have to doctor up both with extra vinegar to counter the sweetness. It also depends on my mood but I'll say I choose macaroni more

[camellia0]

Potato salad is yummy!

[lmrbean]

I prefer potato salad, the regular kind made with mayonnaise.  My husband likes German potato salad, which is vinegar based.  I used to make it for summer barbecues all the time, but over the years I stopped, because my family didn't care much for it.  I have been craving it lately, so might make a small batch for myself one of these days.  Bj's carries a tasty one also.

[nmbrown863]

I have never really liked potato or macaroni salad.

[JediJohnnie]

I like them both. It's too tough for me to pick one over the other.

[tantricia44]

Mac & cheese please!

[ladycasshmere]

Potato salad