Macaroni or Potato Salad - which are your favorite to eat or make?

[pkrahmer]

I love them both but can't have them often Macaroni is much easier to make. I don't like making potato salad at all. However if I had to pick a favorite to eat that would be it.

[dbsaus1]

I love creamy potato salad with eggs. I have not found a recipe that I like so I do not make my own. I  do make hot german potato salad. Very simple but very good.

[ladavia89]

I don't like either. I'll tolerate macaroni and cheese because I do love both pasta and cheese. I can't stand mayonnaise so I won't even touch potato salad

[rob110]

I would have to say I like them both equally. They are always welcomed on my plate and I prefer to have someone else make them.

[dsawan]

both

[catchow]

I enjoy making and eating both I put the same ingredients in both, just one has potatoes one has macaroni

Hmmm has anyone every put potatoes and macaroni in the same salad?

[camellia0]

I love potato salad with lots of eggs! I would make that any time. So yummy.

[cathy37]

They are both good.  My grandmother when she was alive made the best macaroni salad.  My daddy make good potato salad.  My daughter found a recipe for baked potato salad that is delicious

[lguzman1]

It depends who makes them. I like them both. My daughter makes very good Macaroni salad and I like this restaurant macaroni salad. Potato Salad will I really don't eat it anywhere; I don't like. Some of my family makes it very good, so for the answer to this question I think Macaroni will have to win on this one.

[snuggleycutejc]

Hands are up here, I love ems both the same.

[patapon555]

Potato salad is better. I think the potato helps count some of the sickness feeling that macaroni salad can give you

[gsdoss]

Potato Salad by far

[plennis]

I do not like to eat either one.  But my family loves them.  I do not mind making either, usually I make both at the same time.  Nice to have in the refrigerator all cold to go with any meat that I get out to prepare. 

[tnshpalmer85]

I prefer potato salad. I don't really mess with macaroni salad. I may have a bite or two.

[braggin]

I like both potato and macaroni salad although we almost never have macaroni salad in the house as my husband, the cook in our household, likes to make potato salad and does it a lot in the summer. So the only time I ever really get macaroni salad is at other people's houses (which they usually bought at the supermarket already prepared.)