Macaroni or Potato Salad - which are your favorite to eat or make?

[linderlizzie]

Potato salad is my favorite. I like to make it 'cause then I can eat it!  I like macaroni salad but it does not "move" me like potato salad does.

I have one friend who makes a great potato salad but she will not eat it!!

I have another friend who would eat macaroni salad until she fell over dead if she could!!! Well, perhaps that was a slight exaggeration.

[appy9104]

It really depends as I have had some incredible ones of each and some horrible ones.  I guess in general the macaroni salad is "safer" bet to be "good".  I have too many bad potato salads, simple thing like not cooking the potato enough really can ruin it! 

[lywb2168]

I make either one of them Macaroni salad is easier to make, and I personally like it more, but now if my dad is making the potato salad then I will eat the whole thing, his is the best

[alarisracing]

Macaroni salad!!

[aflyingmonkey]

I don't make or eat either one.

[debidoo]

I love to eat both or either.  However agree potato salad is hard to make.  I either under do or over do the potatoes.  I love it and have been craving it lately but I don't like it "store bought" and I just can't stand the thought of making it.  I might just have to give it a try though one saturday or sunday.

[themrs13]

I love to eat them both .... but i would make macaroni 1st because the kiddo like macaroni more

[bigfoot951]

I definitely prefer potato salad.  I really like it, plus I am just not a fan of macaroni salad.

[stretch1967]

I prefer pasta salad

[schoolvan]

I like both I eat very little of rither not allowed to eat much.